Best Smokeless Ashtrays of 2022: Are They Effective?

  • No one likes to smoke inside these days. It turns your walls yellow, makes everything stink, and visitors might have smoke sensitivities. As much as you’d like to go outside, it’s not always possible. Bad weather, mobility issues, or just plain inconvenience are all reasons you might find yourself lighting up inside.
  • The good news is that there’s a type of product you can buy to eliminate the smoke and eliminate a large amount of the adverse effects of that smoke causes. They’re called “smokeless ashtrays,” and they’ve exploded in popularity over the last few years.

What Is a Smokeless Ashtray?

A smokeless ashtray is a device used to collect cigarette and cigar smoking waste. The device uses an electric fan (or some other kind of air circulation) to pull smoke from the burning cigarettes and cigars into a holding chamber. This chamber contains water, which absorbs the smoke particles. The water can be emptied out at any time for disposal, or it can be recycled for use in another capacity (such as watering plants).

How to Use It

The most basic method of using an electronic ashtray is to simply place the burning end of your cigarette or cigar into the opening of the device, where it will be pulled into a holding chamber. As long as you keep your finger on the trigger that activates this process, your cigarette will continue to burn while being pulled into the holding chamber by way of wind generated by an internal fan. Once this process is complete, turn off the power switch associated with your particular model and empty out any collected waste in order to recycle it or dispose of it appropriately.

Do They Really Work?

If you take the name of the product literally – the “smokeless” part – you might be disappointed. No smokeless ashtray will eliminate smoke completely, but the best ones do a pretty darn good job if used correctly and are well maintained.

It’s natural to be skeptical, especially when you see that traditional air purifiers are so expensive, so how can these ashtrays do the same thing but so much cheaper? Smokeless ashtrays are designed to be cost-effective and don’t have quite as much technology built into them. The fans and carbon filters still do a fantastic job at significantly reducing the amount of smoke pollution in your home or other closed space

Why should you Use a Smokeless Ashtray?

We’ve already mentioned a few reasons at the beginning of this article, and if you’re here you probably already have a few reasons of your own. 

Second-hand smoke is proven to be dangerous, and you probably don’t want to expose your guests to health risks for wanting to visit you. The smoke also buries deep into your carpets and furniture and is challenging to get out without professional cleaning.

Just because you smoke doesn’t mean you want it affecting every part of your existence. Sometimes it’s nice to be able to light one up and not have to deal with the offputting after-effects.

These days people are often more mindful of the health of their pets. Second-hand smoke is just as harmful to them as it is to us.

Best Smokeless Ashtrays

The only thing left now is to decide which one is worth parting with your hard-earned money. There are tons of them available, but we’ ll go over a few we like the best to make the decision easier for you.

1) Holmes Smoke Grabber

Holmes HAP75-UC2 Smoke Grabber, Air Purifier,...
  • ELIMINATE ODOR: Includes a specialized carbon filter that helps absorb smoke and...
  • EASY TO CLEAN: Features a dishwasher-safe and removable tray
  • EASY TO USE: Automatically operates upon raising the lid. Ashtray can also be...

Last update on 2022-08-25 at 17:38

Best Quality for the Price

The Holmes Smoke Grabber is one of the most popular ashtrays you can buy today. It gives you the best bang for your buck out of all the ashtrays we mention here.

The Holmes Smoke Grabber is simple to use; just pop open the top and let it do its thing. When you open the cover, a built-in fan turns on automatically. When you finish your smoke, you can close the cover to shut off the fan.

Its basic design makes it a breeze to clean within no time at all. A soft, damp cloth wiped gently over the surface will do the trick. The carbon filters cost very little and are simple to replace.

2) Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray

World's Best Smokeless Ashtray
  • The Smokeless Japanese Ashtray Helps Clear the Air of Smoke and Odors!
  • This Listing Includes: Smokeless Ashtray with 2 Active Carbon Filters
  • Ashtray: Made of Melamine/Phenolic / Cover: Made of Melamine/Phenolic

Last update on 2022-08-25 at 17:38

Manufactured with Fireproof Melamine

Fireproof Melamine is an excellent choice for a device which holds things that are literally on fire. Aside from that, the Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray provides an excellent function for the price. The fan is slightly less powerful than the Holmes version but works well nonetheless.

The full-cover design of this smokeless ashtray makes it look quite stylish and futuristic. There are holes around the perimeter designed to hold your cigars or cigarettes. The built-in fan does all the work at this point. Place your smoke back in the hole after each puff for maximum effectiveness.

The most significant disadvantage of the Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray has to be the size of the holes. While most of your smoking choices will fit just fine, some fatter brands of cigars won’t fit.

3) Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtray

Last update on 2022-08-10 at 14:25

Designed for Cup Holders in Vehicles

It is constructed from fireproof ingredients, the Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtrayhits the number one spot of all smokeless ashtrays for vehicles. It’s easy to carry around because of its compact design and fits perfectly into almost any car’s cupholder. It even includes an LED light.

If you like to smoke while you drive, this smokeless ashtray is perfect for you. It’s effortless to clean and dump and provides excellent all-in-one ash and smoke containment solution.

4) Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray

Smart TV Solutions Battery Operated Smokeless...
  • Built-in filter system reduces second-hand smoke
  • Helps reduce both cigarette and cigar odors
  • Washable filter for long-lasting performance

Last update on 2022-08-10 at 14:25

Reusable and Easy to Clean Filter

Here is another open-top option to consider. The Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray uses batteries and is designed to be compact and portable. You can take it anywhere you go with ease.

A considerable advantage of this smokeless ashtray is the ability to remove and clean the carbon filter when it gets clogged with tar and nicotine. That means you’ll save more money in the long run because you won’t have to replace your filters as often as you normally would.

Something to consider is the fan on the Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray is louder than most models of smokeless ashtrays we’ve tested. It might be more suitable for a garage or camp than a quiet apartment or house.

5) Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray

Talon Development Capture Ionic Smokeless...
  • No filters required
  • Completely Silent
  • Advanced Negative Ion Technology

Last update on 2022-08-10 at 14:35

Uses Negative Ion Technology

As the only model on this list that you can plug directly into an outlet, the Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray is an ideal choice for someone who has a favorite smoking chair. Someone who doesn’t need to move their ashtray around very often. 

Since it doesn’t depend on batteries, you’ll never have to fear that you’ll run out of power, and you’ll save a bit of money over time, too. Don’t worry; if you really want to travel with it, it still takes batteries as a backup option.

The Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray is the only one on this list that uses negative ion technology. Instead of sucking the smoke particles through a filter with a fan, it gives off an electrical charge to eliminate any contaminants.

6) Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray

Smokeless Ashtray Smoke Free Ash Tray Battery...
  • Washable Filter For Long-Lasting Performance
  • Built-In Filter System Reduces Second-Hand Smoke
  • Helps Eliminate Both Cigarette And Cigar Odors

Last update on 2023-07-17 at 18:01

Cheap and Effective

The Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray is excellent if you’re looking for a low-cost option to help reduce the volume of smoke pollution from your cigarettes. It’s best used as a temporary solution because it’s a bit loud and the fan isn’t as strong as a lot of the other models. It’s also made from lower quality material so it might not last as long.

All of those disadvantages are the tradeoff for it being so cheap, and many people only want something basic, anyway. It won’t catch all of the smoke, but it will significantly reduce the amount that gets in the air.

Best Alternative to Smokeless Ashtrays

Smokeless ashtrays do a decent job of eliminating smoke at the source, but even the most effective ones won’t get it all; they only work when the cigarette is sitting directly on them. Personal mini air purifiers are something else to consider to keep your home fresh.

These air purifiers are more expensive than smokeless ashtrays, but they also clean the air more thoroughly and last much longer than ashtrays.

GermGuardian AC4100 3-in-1 Air Cleaning System

Germ Guardian AC4100 11” 3-in-1 True HEPA...
  • 3-IN-1 DESKTOP AIR PURIFIER - True HEPA air filter reduces up to 99.97% of...
  • COMPACT DESIGN - 11-inch tabletop purifier is perfect for smaller rooms or...
  • KILLS GERMS - UV-C light helps kill airborne viruses such as influenza, staph,...

Last update on 2022-08-10 at 14:35

If we were to choose only one alternative to smokeless ashtrays, the mighty GermGuardian AC4100 3-in-1 Air Cleaning System is it. Just like most of the other smokeless ashtrays, the AC4100 comes equipped with a charcoal filter. Something you won’t see in the ashtrays, however, is a HEPA filter. The HEPA filter removes over ninety-nine percent of unwanted substances from the air.

The initial price might seem intimidating at first, but maintaining it properly will keep the GermGuardian AC41000 running smoothly for decades to come. Smokeless ashtrays will need to be replaced roughly every year or two, even the best ones.

Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier

Holmes Desktop HEPA-Type Filter & Optional...
  • REMOVES UP TO 99% OF AIRBORNE PARTICLES: The Holmes Desktop HEPA-Type Air...
  • INCLUDES IONIZER: This Holmes air purifier features an optional air ionizer that...
  • 70 CADR: Air purifier provides a 70 CADR (Clean Air Delivery Rate)

Last update on 2022-08-25 at 16:35

If you’re looking for something that takes up as little space as possible, the Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier is something to consider. It’s made by Holmes, the same brand that makes our favorite smokeless ashtray, and the quality here is just as high.

Three fan settings give you some customizability to match your habits. No use wasting power having it on full blast if you’re just a light smoker. Every minute, the Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier purifies up to 70 cubic feet of air.

Hamilton Beach TrueAir Room Odor Eliminator

Hamilton Beach TrueAir Room Odor Eliminator...
  • Long-Term Odor Solution: Quiet Fan Pulls In Unwanted Smells That Are Trapped and...
  • Fresh Scent: The Green Meadow Cartridge Offers a Light, Fresh Scent That...
  • Traps and Neutralizes Common Household Odors: Terrific for Eliminating Kitchen,...

Last update on 2022-07-26 at 08:26

If you smoke in only one room of your house or apartment, the Hamilton Beach TrueAir Room Odor Eliminator is the ideal solution. It works best in spaces of up to 100 square feet.

This air purifier boasts not one, not two, but three carbon filters. The filters keep your air clean for three full months before needing replacement, and the energy it uses is less than that of a fifteen-watt lightbulb. You can keep it plugged in and not have to fret about an unexpected power bill. You’ll have to think about it so rarely you might even forget it’s there.

Car Ashtray with Electronic Lighter and LED Light


We’ve taken the time to find you the ten best smokeless ashtrays for your home. They’ll eliminate nearly all the negative effects of smoking indoors, as well as some of the hassle that comes with it. Better yet, they keep everyone involved in the smoking experience happy and healthy. It doesn’t get much better than that.

But that doesn’t mean they’re a perfect solution. Some are expensive, while others don’t really do their jobs that well. If you’re looking to buy one of these products, we strongly suggest you read this article and give our Smokeless Ashtray Reviews a look. It has everything you need to know to make an informed purchasing decision, and will hopefully steer you towards a product that’s both effective and affordable. The more smoke you can get rid of from your home, the healthier it will be for yourself and anyone who lives with you!

Category: Guides

Read Next